Showing posts with label The French Lieutenant's Woman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The French Lieutenant's Woman. Show all posts

Thursday, May 15, 2025

To Document, or Experience?

 Wendall--every other Thursday

I recently mentioned John Fowles and The French Lieutenant's Woman to my students and saw utterly blank faces. That prompted me to revisit this post about him, since the "clicking" phenomenon only increases and the quote from Daniel Martin that has haunted me since 1978 is more and more relevant.

 

John Fowles has had an enormous impact on me as a reader and a writer, ever since I swiped my parents’ Book of the Month Club copy of The French Lieutenant’s Woman at age eleven. 

 

The first U.S. edition cover.
 

The cover of the book drew me in, immediately, and I still have that worn original copy, which I carried to college with me and have kept ever since..

 

The first paragraph, one long, glorious sentence, grabbed me instantly, with a phrase that still burns in my brain— “. . . Lyme Regis being that largest bite from England’s outstretched southwestern leg. . .”

 

The famous Cobb in Lyme Regis. Years later, I visited this gorgeous spot.


The rest of that paragraph sent me to the dictionary to look up the word "eponym,” and I kept my Webster’s beside me for the rest of the read. Just Fowles’s words alone probably got me through my SATs, and that habit of keeping a dictionary handy has served me well ever since, especially when I’m reading Cormac McCarthy.

 

Looking back now, as an author, I can truly appreciate the book’s complex structure and revolutionary approach to point of view, along with Fowles’s ability to weave themes of feminism, religion, sexual politics, art vs. nature, and so many others through his work. At the time, I just loved the book. His sentences went straight into me.

 

Of course I went on to devour everything of his I could find, going backward to The Collector and The Magus (my first real impression of Greece, Jeff!) and later forward to The Ebony Tower and, when I was in college, Daniel Martin. 

 

As a college student, bought it hook, line, and sinker.
 

This quote from that book is the one I’ve been thinking about lately:

 

“A lifelong avoider of other tourists, he had forgotten the extent to which every man is now his own image-maker. It was almost frightening, this obsession with capturing through one sense alone, and one that required so little thought or concentration: a mindless clicking. It encouraged the clicker not to remember, above all, not to feel. Perhaps it was the ultimate privilege, on that ship already loaded with unfair advantage of a cultural and economic kind: merely to duplicate seeing, to advertise in some future that one had been there.”

 

At the time, this idea stopped me in my tracks. And in the way only a college student can, I vowed to stop taking photos and, instead, to be present and just burn things on my brain. I did my best to experience, rather than document, for many years after that and I remember those years with a fond, well-lit clarity.

 

But when I see photos from that period, taken by other people, they also delight me and take me back. There are certain photos that I wouldn’t trade for anything—like this one where my glasses are crooked, taken by our “professional photographer” at the Little White Wedding Chapel in Las Vegas. It so completely captures the spirit of our wedding, that it has pride of place on our mantle and always makes me laugh. I am so grateful for it.

 

Nothing like a professional photographer at your wedding!
 

But for someone who loves words, a world where images seem to be the only acceptable currency feels out of balance. From Twitter’s word count limit to Instagram, the whole planet seems to be embodying Fowles’s idea—"a mindless clicking. It encouraged the clicker not to remember, above all, not to feel." And was he right? Do we make a choice between documenting and feeling?

 

Although I was late to smart phones, now that I have one, I am as guilty as anyone when it comes to taking endless photographs. I have so many, I had to buy extra space on Google. So, have I stopped feeling? What do all those photos mean?

 

When I’ve been lucky enough to visit museums and see photographs by Henri Cartier-Bresson, Cindy Sherman, Roy DaSilva, Diane Arbus, Ansel Adams, or Dorothea Lange, there’s no lack of emotion there. It seems to be all feeling.

 

Dorothea Lange documented migrant workers and their families (public domain).
 

But photography as an art form is different from selfies and Facebook cover photos. I wonder what Fowles, who was notoriously private, would say about “the clicking” expected from an author today?

 

The pressure to document (and post) every appearance, every encounter with another author, every book box opening, every recipe realized, every panel, even details of our personal lives, can feel overwhelming. 

 

My husband, a smarter marketer than I, insisted I document this box-opening moment. There's a reason my face isn't in the picture.
 

Can we be present and really meet and listen to our readers, and do selfies at the same time? We can’t know what those photos mean to others, so it’s hard to say which is more important in the long run. Maybe there’s been a redefinition of  “Only connect.”

 

So where’s the balance, between feeling in real time and remembering? Between our public, photo-shopped selves and our deeper natures? How do all these photographs shape our reality? It’s still a conundrum for me. I blame the Book of the Month club.

 

--Wendall 

Monday, August 4, 2014

From The French Lieutenant’s Woman by John Fowles



Here, for your contemplation and in the hopes of stimulating a discussion, is the best description of creating fiction that I can imagine.  It is the beginning of Chapter Thirteen of Fowles’s masterpiece. *



“I do not know.  This story I am telling is all imagination.  These characters I create never existed outside my own mind.  If I have pretended until now to know my characters’ minds and innermost thoughts, it is because I am writing in (just as I have assumed some of the vocabulary and “voice” of) a convention universally accepted at the time of my story: that the novelist stands next to God.  He may not know all, yet he tries to pretend that he does.  But I live in the age of Alain Robbe-Gillet and Roland Barthes; if this is a novel, it cannot be a novel in the modern sense of the word.



            So perhaps I am writing a transposed autobiography; perhaps I now live in one of the houses I have brought into the fiction; perhaps Charles is myself disguised.  Perhaps is it only a game.  Modern women like Sarah exist, and I have never understood them.  Or perhaps I am trying to pass off a concealed book of essays on you.  Instead of chapter headings, perhaps I should have written “On the Horizontality of Existence,” “The Illusion of Progress,” “The History of the Novel Form,”  “The Aetiology of Freedom,” “Some Forgotten Aspects of the Victorian Age” . . .  what you will.
            Perhaps you suppose that a novelist has only to pull the right strings and his puppets will behave in a lifelike manner; and produce on request a thorough analysis of their motives and intentions.  Certainly I intended at this stage (Chap. Thirteen—unfolding of Sarah’s true state of mind) to tell all—or all that matters.  But I find myself suddenly like man in the sharp spring night, watching from the lawn beneath that dim upper window in Marlborough House; I know in the context of my book’s reality that Sarah would never have brushed away her tears and leaned down and delivered a chapter of revelation.  She would instantly have turned, had she seen me there just as the old moon rose, and disappeared into the interior shadows.
            But I am a novelist, not a man in a garden—I can follow her where I like? But possibility is not permissibility.  Husbands could often murder their wives—and the reverse—and get away with it.  But they don’t.
            You may think that novelists always have fixed plans to which they work, so that the future predicted by Chapter One is always inexorably the actuality of Chapter Thirteen.  But novelists write for countless different reasons: for money, for fame, for reviewers, for parents, for friends, for loved ones; for vanity, for pride, for curiosity, for amusement: as skilled furniture makers enjoy making furniture, as drunkards like drinking, as judges like judging, as Sicilians like emptying a shotgun into an enemy’s back.  I could fill a book with the reasons, and they would all be true.  Only one true reason is shared by all of us: we wish to create worlds as real as, but other than the world that is.  Or was.  This is why we cannot plan.  We know a world is an organism, not a machine.  We also know that a genuinely created world must be independent of its creator; a planned world (a world that fully reveals its planning) is a dead world.  It is only when our characters and events begin to disobey us that they begin to live.  When Charles left Sarah on her cliff edge, I ordered him to walk straight back to Lyme Regis.  But he did not; he gratuitously turned and went down to the Dairy.



            Oh, but you say, come on—what I really mean is that the idea crossed my mind as I wrote that it might have been more clever to have him stop and drink milk. . .and meet Sarah again.  That is certainly one explanation of what happened; but I can only report—and I am the most reliable witness—that the idea seemed to me to come clearly from Charles, not myself.  It is not only that he has begun to gain an autonomy; I must respect it, and disrespect all my quasi-divine plans for him, if I wish him to be real.



            In other words, to be free myself, I must give him, and Tina, and Sarah, even the abominable Mrs. Poulteney, their freedoms as well.    There is only one good definition of God: the freedom that allows all other freedoms to exist.  And I must conform to that definition.”



*I have copied this out carefully, word by word.  I consider this a fair use of John Fowles’s sentences.  I type them here out of a sense of admiration and wonder, because having just yesterday read them for the fourth or fifth time, I cannot think of anything better I can say about what it means to write fiction.


Annamaria - Monday