When I was in elementary school, the news circled the globe: Edmund Hillary was the first man to climb
Mount Everest. Hillary was feted world
wide, made headlines in all the newspapers, later was knighted by the Queen. Climbing with the ultra famous Hillary, was a
man whose name did not become well-known until years later. In the reports at the time of the ascent,
Tenzing Norgay Sherpa’s name was misspelled, if not completely
misreported. He was never mentioned in
the headlines, and usually only acknowledged as a “guide” or a “porter.”
At some point during my high school years, when the subject
of Everest came up, it occurred to me to ask about that porter whose name the
newspapers couldn’t get straight. My
youthful heart became enraged that Tenzing Norgay received so little
recognition when it seemed so obvious that Sir Edmund—brave and determined
though he was—would never have made it to the top alone. Tenzing was essential to the success of the
expedition. After I learned about him, I
made it a sanctimonious point to remind anyone who spoke of Hillary that Sir
Edmund did not travel solo. I am sure my
listeners though me obnoxious.
Last week, when sixteen of Norgay’s brother Sherpa mountaineers
died in an avalanche, all that rage against injustice came back and inspired me
to write this remembrance of a man who eventually received recognition, but
never the flood of adulation that was heaped on the white man who was his
partner in that great adventure.
On the 29th of May 1953, Edmund Hillary, a New
Zealand adventurer and Tenzing Norgay, a Nepalese Sherpa mountaineer, together
reached the summit of the tallest mountain on earth. Neither
one of them ever revealed which of the two actually put the first boot on the
peak. Hillary got most of the
credit. But we can’t blame him for
hogging the limelight. He honored
Tenzing and cited his enormous contribution.
Hillary had very good reason to do so, as you will soon learn. The western world at large, however, looked upon
the triumph over Everest as the accomplishment of man of Northern European
descent. Hillary was their hero. They pictured his shorter, browner fellow
traveler as not much more than a servant.
Let’s focus on that “porter” for a few minutes.
Tenzing Norgay was a Nepalese Sherpa born and brought up in the
northeastern town of Tengboche, Khumbu.
His actually birthdate went unrecorded, but he knew he was born in the
Tibetan Calendar’s Year of the Rabbit, which would have been 1914. He also knew he was born in late May—so he
took the date of May 29th—the day he and Hillary reached the
summit—as his birthday. He was the 11th
of 13 children and one of few to survive.
His first opportunity to attempt Everest came in 1935. Chosen for his attractive smile, he joined an
expedition led by an Englishman, Eric Shipton.
During the 1930’s, he went up the mountain’s northern, Tibetan face with
three ensuing British teams. None
succeeded.
During World War II, Tenzing worked in India as a batman for
a Major Chapman. There, his wife died
and he eventually returned to Darjeeling with his two little daughters,
escaping during the 1947 Indian partition by donning one of the Major’s old
uniforms and crossing the continent by train without a ticket.
Once back in the mountains, he joined another unsuccessful
attempt with a Canadian and another Sherpa.
A strong storm stopped them at 22,000 feet (6700 meters). Tenzing continued to hone his mountaineering
skills, with many achievements, including a daring rescue of a fellow member of
a Swiss expedition and the first successful ascent of the Kedarnath peak in the
western Himalayas.
In 1952, on another Swiss attempt, he and another climber
reached 28,200 (8600 meters) on the south face of Everest.
Early the following year, he met Edmund Hillary on an
expedition led by John Hunt. Hillary
nearly fell into a crevasse, but the quick-thinking Tenzing saved him by
securing the rope to his ice ax. After
that Tenzing became Hillary’s partner of choice.
On the 28th of May, Hunt directed Hillary and
Norgay to try for the summit. They made it up to 27,900 feet that day, spent
the night in a tent, and went for the top the next morning. Carrying 30 pounds of gear on their backs,
wedging themselves up between the rock wall and the ice, their final step was
to go straight up for 40 feet. At 11:30
AM, they reached the peak of the highest place on earth: 29,028 feet (8848
meters).
Afterwards, while Tenzing was greeted with adulation in
India and Nepal, the West’s honors went largely to Hillary. He and also Hunt, who didn’t even make it to
the top, were knighted by the Queen.
Tenzing Norgay had to settle for the George Medal.
He went on to become the first Director of Field Training at
the Himalayan Mountaineering Institute.
Eventually Tenzing Norgay’s name even made a few appearances
in popular culture: a mention in a song in Mel Brooks’ The Producers is one of a couple of instances. If you have not known it before, I ask you to
remember it now.
Just yesterday morning, National
Geographic published an article about Sherpa mountaineers, called “The
Invisible Men of Everest. You can find
it here:
Annamaria - Monday
So, uh huh, you've always been like this, Annamaria? I'm SO proud of you! I never knew Hillary had been as gracious to Tenzing as he was. It's good to hear that those who do--as opposed to critique and publicize--appreciate and acknowledge what it really takes to climb the mountain.
ReplyDeleteJ, I learned my sense of justice and fairness from my father around the family dinner table. I also grew up at the time and in place where people of my ethnic stripe were maligned but the "fair-haired people of the north." So, in a way, I had no choice but to care passionately about slights such as those Tenzing received.
DeleteHillary was, unlike many others, and sadly unlike today's mega-rich climbers, utterly fair in his treatment of Tenzing. I had not seen the plaque above until I researched this post. It brought tears to my eyes. Hillary knew!
Wonderful piece, Annamaria. What a lovely tribute to a man who should have been a sung--as opposed to unsung--hero right from the start.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Zoe. The biggest community of Sherpas outside Nepal is here in NYC, in Queens--the borough of 150 languages! They had a memorial service for the the men who perished last week and are raising money for their families. The super-rich use their services but do not seems inclined to sing their praises, even now. Nor worry about how many die. But there are those of us who do care.
DeleteEver the case. You only have to look at the injustice done to the Gurka regiments by the British masters they served so well. But that, as they say, is another story ...
DeleteThank you Annamaria for this.
ReplyDeleteAn appropriate tribute at a time when the Sherpas in Nepal are contemplating a strike to highlight the danger of their work.
ReplyDeleteMichael, the link above is to a NatGeo article that covers their circumstances. It's too bad the world waited for sixteen to die at a clip before it took any notice. I hope they can get enough support to improve their lot.
DeleteThanks Annamaria. I recall the drawings in my 'New Worlds To Conquer' school book, and to my recollection, Tenzing and Hillary had equal billing by then - at least at our school.
ReplyDeleteI think only British citizens or those of the empire can be knighted. 'Sir' Bob Geldof is not a sir due to the fact he is Irish! But I think Tenzing was given the highest honour a non British, non military person can achieve.
From my perspective I have always put the two of them together and on an equal footing so your blog was interesting reading indeed.
Caro, thanks so much for this addition to the story. I'm sure you're right about the knighthood. One source I read said Tenzing was not knighted because it would have caused political problems with the powerful in India, who would have wanted knighthoods for themselves.
DeleteI can't help but observe, steeped as I have become of late in the history of British colonialism, how bemusing it is to know that British children's have schoolbooks are called "New Worlds to Conquer." :-{
You really wouldn't want to know about the map of the world we had to stand in front of and colour in all the territories that Britain had 'conquered'........
ReplyDelete(Miss White, Primary 7. She might have had a personality disorder !! ;) )
Caro, I think I will put a rabidly British nanny named White in my next in the series! Teehee.
DeleteErm, if in doubt, Caro, colour it pink anyway?
Delete