Saturday, March 13, 2010

Irony-Free Zone


One of the things I like best about Southeast Asia is that it's an irony-free zone. People here usually mean what they say, unless they're telling you an outright lie, which happens about as often here as it does everyone else.

What they don't do is snicker at, say, the James Cameron version of Titanic when in fact they've gone through two copies on DVD and an entire supermarket carton of Kleenex waiting for the moment when Jack slips beneath the water. A Southeast Asian is much more likely to say, “Oh, Titanic? I cry too much.”

Or, if they really bawled their eyes out, "I cry too much too much."

The lack of irony also means there's a blessed lack of cool. If there were an international symbol for the Southeast Asian attitude it would be a red circle with a diagonal slash through it, and in the middle would be a pair of sunglasses. Most people here are too busy enjoying, or enduring, their lives to waste time worrying about whether they're being cool.

Cool is a disease as far as I'm concerned, and irony is its indicating symptom. The whole basis of cool is an assumption of superiority. Cool people are above the common herd. They sneer at popular culture, unless it's fashionably bleak. Ask one of them if he or she loves you, and you're likely to get air quotes around the word, “yes.” (Of course, now that air quotes have become uncool – people are using them in Ohio – they're being suppressed, so that the floor around any conversation by the terminally cool is littered with unused air quotes, crumpled little wads of unexpressed impulses.) If cool Americans had their way, the entire North American continent would be creased like an accordion so it can be folded to put New York and Los Angeles next to each other. Or maybe San Francisco.

Tell a cool person about a film (never a movie) with a happy ending, and he'll show you an idiot – you – who enjoyed it. Southeast Asian people like happy endings. They get enough unhappy ones in real life. In Cambodia, where there is literally not one family that wasn't broken tragically under the Khmer Rouge, happy endings are a necessity. Cool is a disease of the overfed and overprivileged.

Here's a stark example of how little cool there is in Southeast Asia. People here go to coffee houses to drink coffee. American coffee houses are little cesspools of cool, places where people wearing expensive cheap-looking black clothes can go to amp up their cool with caffeine while they knock out the next zombie virus movie or – much more likely – talk about knocking out the next zombie virus movie while they conserve battery life by leaving their laptops off. Open, of course (how else will people know it's a laptop?) but off. Why waste cool on a blank page when you can express it out loud?

Only cool people will spend $150 on a pair of jeans that are already ripped. If someone gave that pair of jeans to a Southeast Asian, the needle and thread would come out the moment the donor turned his back. (It would be rude to sew them in front of him.) Most Southeast Asians iron their T-shirts. They may not be able to look rich, but they want to look clean. When they see some rich Westerner (rich means he or she earns more than $200 per week) wearing torn jeans, flap sandals, and a T-shirt that looks like it spent several years crumpled into the smallest possible ball and submerged in mud, they don't see “cool.” They see an idiot. They may not be cool, but they know an idiot when they see one.

The most popular television programs here right now are Korean soap operas, dubbed into Thai, Cambodian, and Vietnamese, and rented for twenty-five cents a disk. Beautifully produced and impeccably acted, they tell the story – over dozens of hours – of beautiful young people who love each other, lose each other, and love each other all over again, crying extravagantly at every major plot point. The crying is real. There are no air quotes around the tears. The guys cry, too.

To make them even less cool, the young people in these shows are virtuous. They don't make love every time the garage door, or the lid on the Dumpster, closes behind them. If they kiss, their tongues take the day off. They work hard. They have dreams, and they strive like hell to achieve them. They (my God!) respect their parents.

A few days ago I walked past an open-air Vietnamese restaurant that was absolutely packed with people, their eyes glued to a small, emphatically low-definition television (let's hear the sneers because it wasn't a flat-screen) that was showing the ninth or tenth hour of the Korean drama “Full House,” which I recognized at once because I've seen it. Often. The impossibly beautiful heroine was in tears, and so was everybody else. Standing at the back of the restaurant, I could hear the sobs. Maybe fifty people were so close to that screen they were practically on the other side of the glass, crying their hearts out over lost love. People whose own lives are far from easy, people who do the best they can, day after day, just to put food on the table. When the episode was over, they looked at each other, saw the tears on everybody else's faces, and started to laugh.

Imagine that. Actual emotions, right out where everyone could see them. In broad daylight.

I could work on this sentence for a week and still not be able to tell you how good it made me feel.

Tim - Sunday

Friday, March 12, 2010

Lynch Mob Rule


I'm beginning to feel a bit like Nostradamus. The plot for my next novel involves a man being killed by a poisoned curry. Lo and behold a few weeks later a story appeared of a woman arrested for murdering her lover by poisoning his curry. Another central theme are two men who killed an old old man when they were children, served time in jail, and then were released despite a tabloid brouhaha, given new identities and a chance at redemption, only for their past to refuse to die. This was loosely based on a real life case here in the UK, one that made headlines across the world: the kidnap and murder of two-year-old James Bulger in 1993 by two small boys, Jon Venables and Robert Thompson, both aged ten. Now the boys, now men, one of them at least, are back in the headlines, a bit like my fictional killers.

The case is now a grim part of British folklore. The chilling CCTV images of the two boys leading the toddler away by his hand imprinted on the nation's consciousness. The details were horrific. It seemed to go against nature. Two young kids who abducted a child in broad daylight in the middle of a busy shopping centre, led him to a violent death, and then degraded and mutilated his body. The outcry echoed for years. For the British tabloids, at the front of the mob, burning torches in hand, it was open and shut: the two boys were evil incarnate. For their awful crimes they should rot in jail for eternity. Every time their names were mentioned, or indeed any time children who killed made the news, or even when a small child was murdered and abducted, the newspapers would call James Bulger's mother  Denise for a comment. Understandably, her hatred for the two boys who killed her son was undimmed. But then she had never had time away from the media to grieve. There is no way you can ever recover from such a loss. However, over time, perhaps you can find some kind of acceptance. No such chance for James' mum. The tabloids kept her grief raw and perpetual, always seeking to obtain a comment and leech her anger. As a reporter I called her once, via her solicitor, got the quote my newspaper wanted - by now she was very practised - but it felt unreal, almost fake. All reporters know there are various 'rentagobs' to whom they go for a colourful quote, usually right-wing, swivel-eyed lunatics who mutter the phrase 'Political correctness gone mad' at any passing hack in return for their name in the papers. It seemed immoral to be using a grieving woman whose son was murdered in the most hideous manner in such a way.

While the tabloids bayed for the boy's blood, those of a more liberal bent struggled. Here was a truly terrible crime. There is no doubt the boys knew what they were doing (though, crucially, whether they fully comprehended the consequences of their actions was another debate entirely.) There was no doubt they should in some way be punished. While the boys' upbringing were not impeccable, neither were they tortured and abused children themselves. For those who don't believe in the existence of evil, in the sense of one being born bad, the case was vexing. There was nothing to explain the horror and, well, evil in the two boys' actions other than small boys have cruel streaks and can sometimes do terrible things. Having a debate about the case with a paid up member of the tabloid lynch mob often felt like you were going to meet a battery of machine guns armed with a peashooter.

The crucial argument was this: given their age, did they deserve the chance at rehabilitation? They had expressed remorse for what they had done. Should they be released to live an adult life, once they had satisfied the authorities they no longer posed a risk to the public? The tabloids howled 'No!'. They had forfeited that right when they murdered a small boy. James Bulger was denied the right to live his life and so should they. It stripped away the almost quaint notion that prison might exist to rehabilitate and reform. It was clear, from the arguments put forward by the tabloids and many of their readers, that prison existed solely to punish. I have spoken to many people who feel life imprisonment was too good for them, that in less enlightened times, they would have been put to death and it would have served them right.

Admirably, I feel, the justice system took a different view. Venables and Thompson became the youngest convicted killers of the 20th century, ordered to serve a minimum of eight years. Under huge public pressure, this was upped several times, at one point to 15 years (by a Tory Home Secretary chasing votes) until the House of Lords intervened and eventually the original term stood. The boys served their time, were assessed and deemed not to be a threat to the public, and were released in 2001. Both were given new identities, for their own protection, despite more howls of outrage, so vociferous and vituperative that they proved the need for aliases. Released under their real names, the two men will have been torn limb from limb by the lynch mob. The men never truly had their freedom though. The tabloids were injuncted to prevent them reporting their new identities, but with their contacts within the police force, their ability to open chequebooks to gain access to protected data, they knew exactly where the two killers were, and started to wait and to watch. Watch and wait...

Last week news broke that Jon Venables had been returned to prison for violating the terms of his parole. The tabloids began to foam at the mouth. What had he done? The public should be told. James' mother was wheeled out to demand information, tabloid reporters cowering behind her as she did their dirty work. The Home Secretary, Jack Straw, did as he he has done throughout his political career, vacillated. He ummed and ahhed and met with James' mum, and eventually decided not to release the details of what Venables had done to the press for fear of compromising his identity. During the days that he dithered, the newspapers had a field day. Venables had been caught looking at child pornography they chanted. The lynch mob leader, The Sun, rated it four out five on some perverted scale, as if they were connoisseurs (The Sun features naked women on page three. Some as young as 17. Wonder where that rates on the scale of child pornography?) They also revealed that he liked to watch violent films. No further questions, m'lud.

For those of who us who defended the right for Venables to be released, this was troubling. Though not because he had apparently re-offended. For a start, he doesn't seem to have been charged with a crime. If he is, then given the recent newspaper coverage, it will be impossible for him to get a fair trial. Why has the Home Secretary deemed it suitable to discuss this with the press in the absence of any charges? Why has he or the Attorney General not warned the newspapers they are getting dangerously close to revealing Venables new identity? Given the cavalier attitude the tabloids now employ towards previous valued ideas of not prejudicing a fair trial, and what can or can't be reported, I wouldn't be surprised if one day one of them says 'To Hell with it' and reports Venables new identity, knowing how toothless the Government has become in dealing with tabloid press excesses. Whereas in the original case, it felt like justice was following its own independent course, irrespective of what was being written and broadcast, it now feels like the tabloids are leading and justice follow in their slipstream. That once, feelings of revenge and the thirst for vengeance were channeled through the rule of law, but now the opposite seesm to be taking place. A cartoon by Steve Bell of The Guardian summarised these feelings far more eloquently than the even the most cogent article could.


Venables is back behind bars. Child pornography is terrible and hateful and if he's guilty he should be charged and punished. However, we don't know if that is what he's supposed to have done and there is the insinuation from some quarters that the material has been planted on him, to frame him, which unfortunately sounds quite plausible. Who knows how long he will remain in jail, and what will happen when he's released. One thing is for certain, the tabloids will be following him, dogging his every step. And from what I have learned, they have his co-killer Thompson firmly in their sights too. In the glare of the British press, the past is truly inescapable. Once more, fact trumps fiction.

cheers

Dan - Friday

Thursday, March 11, 2010

The Screaming of the Innocent

Unity Dow is an extraordinary woman by any standards, but even more so by the standards of male-oriented Botswana. Born in 1959, she became a lawyer and immediately took up the cause of women’s rights in Botswana. In a landmark case, she challenged the constitutionality of a law which excluded her children from citizenship because of husband is a citizen of the United states. She won this, solidifying the equal gender rights promised by the constitution. Later she became a High Court judge – the first woman member – and served for 11 years. During that time she was one of the justices involved in the High Court challenge that gave the San (Bushman) peoples the right to return to their traditional lifestyle in the Kalahari. At present she is on a commission redrawing the Kenyan constitution.

She is also a talented writer. She has written four novels reflecting deep issues in contemporary Botswana: the struggle between traditional and Western values, the AIDS pandemic (Botswana and South Africa compete for the world’s highest infection rates), and ritual murder.

The Screaming of the Innocent is a powerful and disturbing book. A young girl vanishes; the police guess that she has been eaten by a lion, but the reader knows that she has been ritually murdered for body parts reputed to bestow great power. Years later a female student doing national service in the community comes across a box of clothing which seems to belong to the missing girl. But after she draws attention to it, the box vanishes. She seeks out a friend – now a lawyer – and the two young women pursue the matter together.

The book is good not only because of the intriguing characters and plot, but because the reader finds the premise completely believable because the perspective is purely African. To westerners, witchcraft has become almost flippant superstition – like avoiding a black cat. But in many African cultures it is not only respected and feared, but deeply believed. It is this that Dow manages to capture so well in her novel. She makes no bones about the influence of male dominance being connected with these issues. When her evil characters are plotting the murder, they look for “a man with a hard heart, a heart of stone, a heart of a real man”. And, of course, they find such a man. The heroine follows the twists and turns and seems to be taking us to a successful resolution. But Africa is often not like that.

The book was first published in 2002 by Spinifex Press – a boutique publisher in Australia specialising in books focussing on women’s issues – and subsequently published in South Africa. Fortunately, it is widely available. It is a harrowing book, but one well worth reading.

It is tempting to see the premise of the story as an ingenious (if ghoulish) invention, but it is probably based on a real case which would have been well known to Dow. In 1994 a 14-year-old girl named Segametsi and her friend Monnye decided to sell oranges in Mochudi (a small town where they lived) to raise money for a church trip to Francistown. The girls separated near the house of a man called Mokgalo. Segametsi was never seen alive again. Her body was found with fatal chest wounds and with a variety of body parts removed, possibly while she was still alive. Clearly she had been murdered to harvest these organs for Dipheko, “medicine” made from human flesh.

Nothing about the case was obvious. Circumstantial evidence pointed to Mokgalo and he was held briefly, perhaps for his own safety. Soon he was released. Monnye then came up with a story that Mokgalo previously had made advances to Segametsi. Mokgalo wa held again. And in an almost unbelievable turn of events the murdered girl’s father made a confession that he had accepted a promise of 1,200 pula (about $200) to help with the girl’s abduction. Mokgalo was held for two months. During that time the police became suspicious of the stories they had been told. The father was sent for mental examination. Both the father and the Monnye eventually withdrew their stories, and the suspects were released. This led to rioting in Mochudi and nearby Gaborone and the focus moved from the murder to public order. The police and soldiers reacted violently and many people were injured. One was deliberately killed by a policeman.

The government was under continuing pressure and eventually was obliged to ask Scotland Yard to send a team to independently investigate the murder and the police conduct of the case. This lack of trust in the police and people in authority is all reflected in Dow’s novel.

The policeman who killed the suspected rioter was sentenced for manslaughter and the government paid his family about $100,000 in compensation. Mokgalo won a case for wrongful arrest, but describes himself as a broken man who is still treated with suspicion. The Scotland Yard report has never been made public. No one has been arrested for the murder of Segametsi.

In his last post Stan mentioned our meeting with Director Mulale of the CID. When he heard we were mystery writers, he said there was much to write about in Botswana, and mentioned the Segametsi case. I have always wondered why the Director of the investigating department would want this brought up. Also, he must have known about Unity Dow’s novel. What was there to add?

The belief in the power of evil medicines and witches has another somewhat unexpected and damaging consequence. Since witchcraft is used to ensure success in financial and other ventures, it can be dangerous to appear too successful. If you have risen faster and farther than others, is it not possible that you too may have dabbled with Dipheko? This perception may be very dangerous for you indeed. It is safer to be mediocre…

Michael – Thursday.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

The referendum

This past weekend Icelandic voters entered the booths to decide whether or not to pass a law providing a state guarantee of payments to Holland and the UK, used to reimburse former Landsbanki account holders in these countries. The result was an overwhelming No – about 93% of voters rejected the guarantee while approximately 2% agreed, and 5% returned their ballots empty or invalid. Having been in New York and watched how this was misreported in the foreign media: Iceland voters reject paying foreign creditors – I feel myself compelled to explain the issue, albeit to the best of my limited knowledge of state finances.

If what I have picked up during the 1 ½ years since the Icelandic banks collapsed is correct, the issue boils down to the following: The public, government owned Icelandic banks were privatized 8 years ago and highly unfortunately for us and anyone and everyone lending them money, over time these establishments ended up in the wrong hands. At some point the owners came to think of these institutions as their private piggy banks, useful for dipping into whenever they needed cash for a new, usually crummy, business venture. Had the banks been properly managed this would not have been possible, but again unfortunately for everyone, the men chosen to man the bridge were at least one, if not all, of the following: inexperienced, greedy or simply stupid. They were led astray by ridiculous salaries and crazy share options that had not been seen in our country before. The assumption is that if the managers had dared step on the brakes, they would simply have been replaced. Hence they toed the line, on their watch money was squandered left, right and center and the key players became increasingly better off – personally.

Subsidiaries were set up abroad, and in the case of Landsbanki, when the foreign paperwork and operating licenses were too annoying a process, branch offices – such as the horrific Icesave accounts. Both forms of business offered accounts with much higher interest rates than traditional in mainland Europe and the money came pouring in. On top of this, operational loans were available in abundance on the world market and to keep these miserable ventures running the banks took on more and more (and more and more). Not only were new loans used to pay off old loans, they were also taken to keep the snowball effect alive.

Enter the credit crunch. No more foreign loans and the time of reckoning was upon the banks. What were they to do? Their share prices were falling and they were not able to pay off the loans that kept them ticking. Foreign account holders became uneasy and new accounts were few and far between and a rush on the banks was not far off. It was thus imperative for the banks to falsely appear stable and safe. This was not only to head off rush attempts, the owners had a lot riding on share values and the managers as well, their bonuses and stock options were in danger of achieving their true value = zip. But once cornered rats will bite, and the banks did just that: they bit, chewed and spit out the gnawed bones. Gross market manipulation ensued, and this took on many forms, some even ridiculous (involving an imaginary investing Sheik from Dubai). Also, being based in Iceland the bank’s accounting had to be done in Icelandic króna and to cook the books they attacked our currency, making their balance sheets look so much better, i.e. when their foreign assets ballooned in value (in ISK). Tough shit for their former countrymen who were hard hit by this occurrence. At this point it should be noted that most of what these banks owned had nothing to do with Iceland and only a small fraction of what they amassed in loans and accounts ever arrived here. The key players all live in London or Luxemburg you see and their business ventures focused on buying up fancy businesses and foreign companies – the Icelandic market being way too small for their lofty aspirations.

To cut a long story short, in October 2008 the house of cards that the Icelandic banks truly were, came falling down. One by one the three banks that had ventured abroad went bust, leaving in their wake horrible consequences for innocent people and various financial institutions that had been too trusting in their lending. In the latter’s defense, the ratings companies noted nothing amiss, for one Fitch Ratings amazingly repeatedly gave our banks great ratings – the last such “invest/buy” rating being dated less than a month before they collapsed. Makes you wonder what is in the Fitch water cooler.

So what did this mean to Iceland aside from having no more big banks in operation and a next to worthless currency? To explain this properly it must be noted that branch offices are different from subsidiaries as they are not legal, independent entities but operated under the liability of the head office – based in Iceland in the case of Icesave. It is worth remembering that despite this arrangement the money deposited was not shipped to Iceland for safekeeping or any such thing. However, this does not change the fact that when Landsbanki went bust the liability of reimbursing holders of such branch accounts was that of the Icelandic head office. In accordance to the appropriate EU directive for deposit guarantees, Iceland had in place a fund meant to pay back account holders in the case of a bank going bust – note: a bank, not banks. This emergency fund (banks were required to place at least 2% of their deposits into it) had by no means enough to pay back the full amount of what was lost and apparently the directive which Iceland dutifully followed was never meant to address a head-on banking system collapse. Such a fund is not really possible no matter how big the economy and the blame is not to be placed on the EU. What matters is that the insufficient fund bore no state guarantee, any more than other such funds elsewhere.

Finally I get to the point, namely the referendum. After the collapse the British and Dutch governments decided to pay the account holders what they lost, up to an amount approximately double the minimum required in Europe. This is obviously very generous and the right thing to do when it comes to the people involved but things got very complicated when these same governments turned round and requested Iceland pay the full amount back within 7 years – with 5,5% interest and that the Icelandic state guarantee payments. It was this guarantee that was voted upon – i.e. does the Icelandic taxpayer want to guarantee payments for a private bank? Not really. This is not to be misunderstood, we are willing to accept what can be stretched to be considered our responsibility and pay what is required to cover the minimum payment for the accounts in question. Our government was not asked when a much higher payment was made and it certainly would not have agreed – unless of course they had been sipping from the Fitch water cooler.

The Dutch and British claims amount to approximately 4 billion Euros or 5.5 billion USD, perhaps not seeming like a great deal until put in conjunction with the Icelandic population: 320,000 people (presently decreasing for the first time in a century). This is a crazy burden for each family here to bear, about 70,000 USD per family of four, especially considering the horrible state of everything else. The banks dragged almost everything down with them, our currency collapsed for one, and the pillaging for “investing” that has come to light reached further than our banks: our insurance company’s trust funds and almost every single pension fund in the country – scorched earth.

Finally – the lesson to be learned is hard for us. We will do the honorable thing, i.e. pay what is left of the minimum payment once the Landsbanki assets have been sold. What we don’t want to have to do, and can’t really, is pay a high interest rate until everything is sold off and accounted for (estimated to be finalized in 7 years). This will most likely be the result of new, ongoing negotiations with Holland and the UK as all parties are intent on solving the matter and moving forward. There are no real good guys or bad guys in the clean-up operations required by the whole mess, such categories easily chage according to the viewpoint assumed. I guess one thing everyone can agree on: Iceland must promise not to undertake international banking, ever again. A heads up: if this promise is broken in future, steer away from banks ending with -banki.

There are various other aspects that I don’t have space for but can’t completely leave out, namely: our poor politicians (both in power and the opposition) that must tackle this horror and try to run the country for free (no funds available) as well as our president – all of whom have my full sympathy, the fact that Landsbanki accounts within Iceland were paid out in full to avoid an uprising, the IMF refusing to pay out agreed loans until we have accepted the Icesave agreement and as such acting as some sort of collector instead of the helping hand it is supposed to be, in addition to what hurts the most: the refusal of our neighboring Scandinavian countries to lend prior to our signing as well as the cold shoulder Obama has turned towards us, the USA’s allies. When push comes to shove politics fall under no known equations – the important thing is not to mix such dealings with the citizens themselves and hope that they too will accept us here at face value, despite Iceland having bred amongst us the worst banker/investor combos know to man. If accepted, I truly apologize on behalf of my country for the financial wreckage left in their wake.

Finally, I can’t leave the subject without sending my praises to the Faroe Islands and Poland – these two countries provided help not based on us signing any agreements. My sincerest and heartfelt thanks to them, plus what counts: my Eurovision vote.

Yrsa - Wednesday

Monday, March 8, 2010

Squatting in Paris


Squats have always provided a venue for alternative lifestyles and experiments in artistic creation, but in recent times, an increasing number of squatters in Paris have succeeded in transforming illegally occupied spaces into legal art galleries and respectable cultural centers. Could this benevolent trend herald the end of squatting as we know it?

At 59 Rue Rivoli, a street which is bang in the centre of Paris, a group of people have gathered in front of a freshly refurbished building. After three years of renovation work by Paris city hall, owner of the building since 2002, the highly decorated façade of the most famous Parisian squat has been given an insignificant Haussmannian facelift. But you can just about make out the word "Aftersquat" beneath the paint. At the opening ceremony Gaspard Delanoë, president of the artists collective 59 Rivoli, is reassuring those complaining that the place is now looking somewhat too conventional. "Come back in six months!" he says. "Things will have changed!"

But squatters - the term doesn’t quite fit. The Paris municipality is now renting the building to a group of artists for 130 euros a month as they do in several similar places. It’s a subtle difference that some feel needs clarification. "We aren’t squatters," insist the artists from Frigo, a squat which lies in the 13th arrondissement, in the south of Paris site of the old grain silos. "We pay rent to the city." Another artist from 59 Rivoli rolls a cigarette. "We have to evolve because times are changing. From being 'illegal' and 'underground' we have become 'alternative'," he explains. If these changes are constructive from an artistic point of view, the general public seems to be left out. There’s no question of just popping in for a coffee or a beer unless there’s an exhibition on, unlike other, more accessible and participative concepts, such as La Suite in the 13th district. Here, the "Grooms collective" welcome workshops and a variety of good initiatives.

Squats depend on each other in this city. When one is threatened, it’s the whole community that reacts. "We are still running thanks to the Stock Exchange (Bourse) site, which has since been closed down," continues the 59 Rivoli artist as he finishes his cigarette. "And if La Suite is still up and running, it’s due partly to our efforts." The battle continues to be waged. ‘We shall continue to squat and invest in unoccupied buildings to set up art hives wherever possible," promises Gaspard Delanoë. "The reopening of 59 Rivoli is a step in the right direction for artists."

Meanwhile in the Marais another type of squatters took over a vast, vacant 17th-century property, which once belonged to the Marquise de Sévigné, boasts listed rooms with period painted wooden beams and panelling and a spectacular view over the Place des Vosges.

Dominique Strauss-Kahn, the head of the International Monetary Fund, lives directly opposite and Victor Hugo used to dwell next door.

The squatters claim to be a group of highly educated individuals who broke into the 1,400sq ft hôtel particulier to draw attention to the plight of low-paid workers unable to afford housing while countless properties are left vacant. The mansion in question has not been lived in for more than 40 years.

However, they had not banked on its 87-year-old owner storming out of her retirement home to demand they leave. Béatrice Cottin knocked on the arched wooded gate, walking stick in hand, and is demanding compensation of £103,000 a month for illegal occupation. Mrs Cottin owns a string of sumptuous properties, including an estate in Cap Ferrat on the Riviera, hunting grounds in Sologne, north-central France, and land in the Arcachon basin in the south. She also has another luxury town house behind the Musée d’Orsay in Paris.

“She feared for her property. Squatters in her eyes were vandals and would degrade it,” said Stéphane Roques, 36, a literary translator living and working in the mansion, rent-free.

But the 33 squatters, including university students, a pianist, a lawyer and architects, were not what Mrs Cottin had expected.

Cara - Tuesday

Sunday, March 7, 2010

Why Brazilians Hate Orson Welles




 Remember Orson Welles?
Remember his 1939 classic, Citizen Kane, a film that often heads the list of the 10 best ever made?
Brazilians do too.

But they also remember him for a film he shot in their country and never finished, for contributing to the death of one of their national heroes, and for trashing the Copacabana Palace Hotel.
The film he never finished is It’s All True. He visualized it as a series of three vignettes about Latin America. One of the three, entitled Four Men on a Raft, had been inspired by an article Welles read in the December 8, 1941, issue of Time Magazine.


It told the story of four fishermen who set out from Fortaleza , the capital of the northern state of Ceará, to file a grievance with the President of Brazil.  The distance by sea was 1,650 miles. Their craft was a jangada they’d named after Saint Peter, the fisherman.  

Jangadas, still widely used today, are little more than rafts with sails, tiny vessels with virtually no freeboard. They are made for the calm seas of Brazil’s northeast and are totally unsuitable for the rougher waters further south.After 61 days at sea, navigating without instruments, without a motor, without even running lights, the San Pedro’s captain, Manoel Olímpio Meira, nicknamed Jacaré (alligator) brought them safely to Rio de Janeiro.
By the time he sailed into the harbor, he was already a national hero.Gitúlio Vargas, the president (and virtual dictator) of Brazil, was so impressed that he granted the fishermen’s petitions. They and their colleagues were awarded the same benefits enjoyed by unionized industrial workers – retirement funds, pensions for widows and children, housing, education and medical care.Welles decided to re-enact their epic voyage and make it the centerpiece of It’s All True.

He hired the four fishermen to play themselves and leased their jangada. Then, on a blustery day in the (southern hemisphere) fall of 1942, he bade them set sail for the open sea. The conditions that day suited his purposes admirably. He wanted to show how difficult the voyage would have been, how the decks of a jangada would run awash in heavy weather.


Jacaré demurred, told him it was too dangerous. Welles offered him more money. Again, Jacaré refused. So Welles offered him still more. The man was a poor fisherman. The amount he could earn would have fed his family for a year. He decided to take the risk.They’d hardly cleared the embracing arms of the harbor when they were struck by a towering wave. Jacaré was swept overboard and disappeared in the heavy seas. His decomposing head was later found in a huge shark caught a few miles down the coast off the Barra da Tijuca. 

The Brazilian newspapers made much of the disaster. Welles was blamed. The studio management didn’t like the bad publicity, and they particularly disliked the fact that Welles was spending too much of their money. The project was re-evaluated.Welles was ordered to complete Four Men on a Raft with a minimal budget, and a minimum crew, and return to Hollywood.
He threw a hissy fit.


What furniture he didn’t cast out of his windows at the Copacabana Palace, he smashed. More bad publicity. RKO cancelled his contract. The project was abandoned. As for Welles, his career, from then on, was all downhill.He tried to get other studios to back him, but by then word of the enfant terrible’s comportment had gotten around. He wasn’t “serious”. He was unstable. He was (worst of all) a risk. And no one wanted to gamble.He then decided he’d finish the film on his own, and eventually, he managed to purchase some of the footage he’d shot. But the project ended in failure when he was forced to give up ownership because he could no longer pay storage costs for the negative.A few years went by. RKO, having need of space in their vaults, dumped the vast majority of Welles’ footage into the Pacific Ocean.

Fortunately, not all. In 1985, 43 years after shooting ended, some 300 cans turned up in a corner of the old RKO vault. They became the seminal material for a documentary released by Canal Plus in 1993.

Canal Plus is a French pay television channel. The French love Orson Welles. They were also behind a lovely film that he starred in back in 1968, the only one he ever directed in color. 

It’s called Une Histoire Immortelle, and it’s a magnificent piece of work.If you ever get a chance, see both the documentary and Immortal Story. They’re both magnificent.

Leighton – Monday

Saturday, March 6, 2010

The Travel Spoiler

"Why in the world are you going to Thailand?" they ask. (Or Nepal, or Bali, or Finland, or Tierra del Fuego, or the Sea of Tranquility.) "It's been completely spoiled." Then they hoist their beer or shot of Jagermeister or whatever the hell it is, and say, "Now, when I first went there . . ."

And they’re off, reciting the Travel Spoiler’s version of Paradise Lost, describing an era – now vanished in the dim mists of time, when pangolins ruled the earth– an era when the place you’ve been saving money for years to visit was actually worth visiting. The people were friendlier, the streets less crowded, the culture more authentic, the summer cooler, the rainy period briefer, beautiful women threw themselves at men’s feet (you don’t hear much about the reverse), and you could rent a five-room apartment over the river for twenty dollars a month. Oh, and did they mention the women?

When they’ve run out of superlatives to describe the past and negatives to taint the present, they deliver the coup de grace: “I’m finished with Thailand, actually.” (Or Nepal, or Bali, or Finland, or Tierra del Fuego.) “Can’t even stand to go back, it’s changed so much.”

By now you may be so dismayed that you missed the nugget of good news in that last paragraph: Wherever you’re going, this person won’t be there. There will be other Travel Spoilers of various kinds, but this particular one won’t be among them. So cheer up, and let me tell you a secret:

All those places are still wonderful.

I don’t understand why so many people (okay, mostly men) seem compelled to make the point that they experienced the true Thailand or Lhasa or whatever, and what you’re about to enter is some sort of animatronic theme park designed for less discerning travelers. Underlying this attitude is a very specific kind of snobbery. The country you’re going to visit was better then because it was harder to get to, there weren’t good hotels, the roads were scratched in the dirt with a stick. But now, the argument suggests, just anybody can go there. People who wear shorts. People who don’t care about the culture. People, they are suggesting, like you.

Another common thread that runs through the Spoilers’ stories is that the people who live in the country on your itinerary were more eager to accommodate the intrepid explorers of the Golden Age than they are today. No request was too unreasonable; all tourists were treated like Brad Pitt. Any pasty-faced American or European schnorrer teaching English for three dollars an hour could afford four servants. Boil all that down, and you come up with this: back in the days of paradise, the local people were poorer. And now they’re not so poor, and the Travel Spoiler doesn’t like that.

Anyway, if you’re unlucky enough to run up against one of these clowns, ignore him. People have been saying for decades that the earth’s various paradises were spoiled. Before I went to Bali for the first time, I read a classic book written in the 1930s by an artist named Miguel Covarrubias, in which he said repeatedly that Bali had been spoiled. Sixty years after Covarrubias wrote his book, Bali took my breath away. People have been proclaiming Thailand to be over since the 1980s, but it’s still the only Thailand on the planet, and it’s one of the world’s blessed places. Ignore the Travel Spoiler and recognize him for what he is: a snob and a closet colonialist who wants to lord it over the people of any country he condescends to visit.

But I have to tell you, the first time I visited Angkor . . . .

Tim -- Sundays